La conscience des déficits neurocognitifs dans la schizophrénie : une méta-analyse

Stéphane Potvin, Ph. D.; Julie Pelletier MPs; Emmanuel Stip, MD, MSc
Volume 39, numéro 2, automne 2014

Stéphane Potvin, Ph. D.
Centre de recherche de l’Institut universitaire en santé mentale de Montréal ; Université de Montréal ; Montréal, Canada
Département de psychiatrie, Faculté de médecine, Université de Montréal ; Montréal, Canada
Julie Pelletier, MPs
Département de psychiatrie, Faculté de médecine, Université de Montréal ; Montréal, Canada
Emmanuel Stip, MD, MSc
Département de psychiatrie, Faculté de médecine, Université de Montréal ; Montréal, Canada
Centre de recherche du Centre hospitalier de l’Université de Montréal ; Université de Montréal ; Montréal, Canada

Résumé

Contexte La schizophrénie est un trouble allant de pair avec un manque d’autocritique par rapport aux délires et aux hallucinations. En contrepartie, on en sait beaucoup moins en ce qui concerne la conscience des patients par rapport à leurs déficits cognitifs, qui sont des symptômes clés de ce trouble psychiatrique. Afin de faire la synthèse de l’état de la connaissance à ce sujet, nous avons effectué une méta-analyse de 22 études comprenant 1609 patients. Les analyses ont révélé que les patients rapportent davantage de plaintes subjectives que les sujets sains. La corrélation entre la cognition subjective et objective s’est avérée faible toutefois. Les études utilisant la Scale to Investigate Cognition in Schizophrenia ont produit des corrélations plus fortes que celles utilisant d’autres échelles de plaintes subjectives. La relation entre la cognition subjective et les symptômes dépressifs s’est avérée comparable à la relation entre la cognition subjective et la cognition objective. Enfin, une relation faible a été observée entre la cognition subjective et l’autocritique par rapport aux symptômes positifs. Les résultats de la présente méta-analyse montrent que les patients atteints de la schizophrénie se plaignent de déficits cognitifs, mais qu’ils n’ont pas une représentation claire de la nature de ceux-ci, ce qui confirme l’existence de déficits méta-cognitifs dans la schizophrénie.

Mots clés schizophrénie, cognition, autocritique, méta-analyse.

Neurocognitive insight in schizophrenia: a meta-analysis

Abstract

Background: Schizophrenia is well-known to be associated with a lack of insight into symptoms. Comparatively, little is known on insight into neurocognitive deficits in schizophrenia, despite the fact that these dysfunctions are undoubtedly core features of the disorder. Recently, growing interest has been paid to subjective cognition, and thus far, results have been heterogeneous. The objectives of current meta-analysis were to determine the magnitude of subjective complaints in schizophrenia; to examine the association between subjective cognitive complaints and objective cognition, as well psychiatric symptoms and insight into illness. The meta-analysis also sought to determine if results are influenced by the choice of the scale used to measure subjective cognition.
Methods: A search was performed with PubMed, PsycInfo and EMBASE, using the following key words: schizophrenia OR psychosis AND cognition OR memory OR attention OR “executive functions” AND insight OR “subjective cognition” OR awareness. Studies involving patients with schizophrenia-spectrum disorders and measuring subjective cognition with a validated self-report scale were included. Studies using scales measuring insight into thinking processes (e.g. Beck Cognitive Insight Scale) were excluded. Statistical analyses were performed with the Comprehensive Meta-Analysis-2 software. Cognitive scores were grouped into 6 cognitive domains (as recommended by the MATRICS group): attention, problems solving, speed of processing, verbal memory, visual memory and working memory. The difference in cognitive complaints between schizophrenia patients and healthy controls was examined using Cohen’s d. The associations between subjective cognition and objective cognition, psychiatric symptoms and insight into illness were examined using Pearson’s correlation coefficients.
Results: Twenty-two studies were retrieved, including a total of 1609 patients and 294 controls. Patients reported increased subjective cognitive complaints, compared to controls (moderate effect size). A weak association was observed between subjective and objective (global) cognition. The association was larger in studies using the Subjective Scale To Investigate Cognition in Schizophrenia (SSTICS), compared to studies using other scales. The largest association was observed between subjective complaints and problem solving. The association between subjective complaints and depressive symptoms was in the same range as the association between subjective complaints (measured with the SSTICS) and objective cognition. No association was found between subjective complaints and positive / negative symptoms. Finally, a weak association was found between subjective complaints and insight into illness.
Discussion: Taken together, these results suggest that schizophrenia patients report significant subjective cognitive complaints. However, patients have a poor understanding of these deficits, since subjective complaints are as strongly associated with depressive symptoms as they are associated with objective cognitive deficits. Schizophrenia patients may be more aware of their problem solving deficits. However, this observation is based on a limited number of studies and will need to be replicated in future studies. Our results also show that insight into neurocognitive deficits is largely independent from insight into illness. Finally, the results of the current meta-analysis may have methodological implications, since they suggest that the SSTICS produces stronger associations between subjective and objective cognition than other scales. In the future, greater attention will need to be paid to the domains of subjective complaints, as well as to subjective cognitive complaints in other psychiatric disorders.

Keywords Schizophrenia – cognition – insight – meta-analysis

Auteur : Stéphane Potvin, Ph. D.; Julie Pelletier MPs; Emmanuel Stip, MD, MSc
Titre : La conscience des déficits neurocognitifs dans la schizophrénie : une méta-analyse
Revue : Santé mentale au Québec, Volume 39, numéro 2, automne 2014, p. 183-200

URI : http://id.erudit.org/iderudit//1023986ar
DOI : 10.7202/1027839ar